Book Review: Pictures of Lily by Paige Toon

Posted By Leah on July 7th, 2010

When Lily moved to Australia with her mother aged 16, the last thing she expected was to fall in love with someone, but fall in love she does. It doesn’t help, though, that the man she falls in love with not only has a girlfriend in England, but is also twelve years older than her. When he departs for England to join his girlfriend Lily is heartbroken and finds that, even 10 years later, she still can’t forget him.

So when her boyfriend of two years, Richard, proposes, she’s quite literally gobsmacked before eventually accepting despite the fact she can’t forget the man who broke her heart a decade ago. So what’s Lily going to do when her past comes back to haunt her and she realises that she will have to break the heart of one of the men who loves her?


If you haven’t read any of my Paige Toon reviews then you won’t know just how much I love her books. Until now; I love Paige Toon’s books. Lucy In The Sky was fantastic, Johnny Be Good was even better and Chasing Daisy was stunning. I’ve read them all multiple times and I still marvel at how well written they are and how much I love them. I also love going back and connecting the dots because all of Paige’s characters re-appear in her later books and it’s so good figuring out who we’ve already met in previous books. I’ve been waiting for a new Paige Toon book since, you know, July last year when I read Chasing Daisy. Even more so when I heard about Pictures of Lily, I loved the sound of it and was so happy to receive a copy earlier this week. And, because I have no self control, I started it almost immediately.

Pictures of Lily is done a bit differently to Paige’s previous three books. There’s the standard prologue, which is set in the present day, in which Lily’s boyfriend Richard proposes and whilst Lily ponders the question, we head back to 10 years ago when Lily first moves to Australia. Then for the next 175 pages we learn about Lily’s life as a 16-year-old. What it was like to move to Australia and be wrenched away from everything she’s ever known just so her mum could be with a man she met on the Internet, how she ends up accompanying her mum’s boyfriend Michael to the animal sanctuary where he works and ends up loving it and then, falling in love with someone, Ben, who is twelve years her senior, has a girlfriend and is moving to England to be with said fiancee. I thought it was a stunning opening to the book. I was immediately sucked into Lily’s 16-year-old self and I was hooked.

We then move back to the present day which follows immediately from the Prologue where Lily is being proposed to by Richard (at a wedding, no less). After reading all about what happened to Lily when she was younger, it was easy to see why she was so hesitant and it was equally as easy to see why she was still hooked on Ben. I worried that maybe I would just see it as a teenage crush and that Lily should have gotten over it years ago but it wasn’t like that at all. Paige writes the first 175 pages so well that it would be far too mean to just brush off Lily’s love for Ben because it just comes across so real and all consuming. I must admit, I did find the present day part of the book a little bit slow. After the fast pace of the first 175 pages, it all seemed to slow down a little. That’s not a criticism at all, though, and I eagerly awaited the arrival of someone from Lily’s past because for me, it couldn’t come soon enough!

Much like Lucy, Meg and Daisy before her, I absolutely loved Lily. I adored her 16-year-old self and could have read an entire book about her at that age. She doesn’t have an easy time of it at 16 and she handled it well. To then still be pining over Ben after a decade made for sad reading. It was clear that he had really helped her when she first moved to Australia despite the fact it all took place in such a short amount of time. Like Lucy, Meg and Daisy, Lily is warm and funny and just as down to Earth as the others. I have to say I liked Ben from the off. He’s a huge part of Lily’s new life in Australia, as I said, everything that takes place within the first period of the book made complete and total sense to me. Surprisingly I liked Richard, Lily’s boyfriend ‘now’. He was nice, and was good to Lily. But obviously, I always preferred Ben. There are other characters who make appearances but no one regular enough to be honest. Although I did like Michael and Josh, Lily’s mums boyfriend (and the reason for their move to Australia) and his son.

Paige Toon is an incredible writer. Her writing flows so easily and is such a pleasure to read. I knew that once I began reading Pictures of Lily I would have to finish it on the same day and I did. I managed to finish it in about 5 hours, it was that readable. As I said, the thing Paige does best is bringing back her characters from her earlier books and they’re all mentioned here; Lily is friends with Lucy and Nathan, she sees Luis on the telly (“snogging his gorgeous girlfriend”) and she had posters on the wall of Fence (the band Johnny Jefferson was part of until he went solo) as a 16-year-old. Even Richard, Lily’s boyfriend, appeared in an earlier book, causing me to speed over to my bookshelf to check I was right (I was!). It always makes me smile when I hear from previous characters and to know their life is going well. Pictures of Lily is definitely another hit from Paige and I wholly recommend it. It’s just as good as her previous three books and having read Pictures of Lily, it means the countdown is on for her sequel to Johnny Be Good which is going to be her next book!

I’d like to thank the publishers for sending me this to review.

Similar Posts

18 Responses to “Book Review: Pictures of Lily by Paige Toon”

Sarah

I can’t wait to read this!

Sib

i’m stupidly excited about this book :D

Rossy

Fantastic review, Leah!

Nicole

i loved this book. i did kind of wish josh had more “screen” time. haha. i would have loved to read more from him… yum.

Donna Louise

I loved Pictures of Lily!! Another incredible book by Paige Toon. I enjoyed it just as much as the 3 previous books and loved the connection back to Lucy and Nathan, Sam and Molly. Lucy in the Sky was amazing so I was so excited to read that they got married :)
I felt like i could connect so much to this book as i’m going through the same kind of thing as Lily…theres always The One that you’ll never forget so it was like Paige was reading my own mind
Bring on the next one x

Jasmin

I finished Pictures of Lily last night and I hate to say it (because I love Paige Toon), I didn’t like it at all. I found it boring - there was no “I can’t put it down” factor like in all the other books. Lily really annoyed me and was not likable. Why say “yes” to a marriage proposal if you actually don’t want to marry him? Also, as if a 28 years old guy would fall for a 16 years old girl. Seriously, that’s so not believable. Yes, it was nice to hear about Nathan, Lucy etc but it just wasn’t an enjoyable read. Now I am looking forward to her next book, the sequel of Johnny Be Good.

Jez

I have to agree with Jasmin. I Loved Loved Lucy in the Sky the other two where good. I found thats there wasn’t that “couldn’t put down” factor. I was left feeling so sorry for Richard and didn’t like how “Ally” was introduced into the story it seemed like abit of a cop out. Agreed 28 year old falling for a 16 year was old abit hmmm. I found myself wanting to hear more about Lucy and Nathan then I did Lily. I just found it slow and frustrating.
Can’t wait for the next book though.

Rhona

I have to agree with the previous two posts! i am a huge fan of paige and have read her books over and over again…especially chasing daisy which i absolutely loved. But pictures of lily just didnt do it for me :( i felt i didnt connect with lily at all. i lked her younger self but when the book jumped forward to the present time it was very slow and full of angst. i found myself unable to relax when reading it and it was obvious we were waiting for ben to appear at some point. I dont think i’ll be reading it again which is a shame as i do love her writing. But cant wait to read the sequel to johnny be good!

Caz

I’m just about to read it but can someone fill me in as I have read all Paige toon’s other books and forgot which one Richard was in and what was he in that book before pictures of lily

Leah

Richard was in Lucy in the Sky and if I remember correctly he stayed in the same flat as Nathan when Nathan came to England.

Caz

Oh yeah I remember now thanx Leah :-)

Caz

Also Leah was he the one who went out with lifts friend from work?

Caz

*Lucy

Marie

Hmmm, I too have so far enjoyed all of Paige Toon’s previous books and was very much looking forward to reading this new one. As such, I was NOT impressed last night when I got to page 138 and find that there are 50 pages missing!!!! Yes that’s right, you go from reading about Lily talking to Ben in the zoo to her being at dinner with Richard. Not impressed!! I’m hoping that no-one else has to go through this and that the publishing company have managed to rectify this problem with any other copies who may also have missing pages.

Caz

I just finished this book and I thought it was brilliant just like her others aswell. Looking forward to her next one!

Claire

All of Paige’s books are fab… Her next book Baby Be Mine is out on 21/7/11! I can’t wait.

Paige is on the book of many faces also there is a Paige Toon group… check it out if you are fans x

Hannah

this book was recomended to me by a girl who works in waterstones. i was’nt so sure about it at first but, WOW! i read it in less than a day, thats how glued i was to it! im not really much of a ready and i was just looking around when i bought it. i was so into the book i had butterflies for lily as i was reading it! ive never been so excited about finishing a book and finding out what happens in the end. this was an amazing book and i cant wait to read more of paige toons books!!!

jackie

had this book given to me…couldn’t put it down, had to find out what happens

Leave a Reply